Donna moss and josh lyman relationship trust

West Wing stars: Josh and Donna would still be together |

donna moss and josh lyman relationship trust

The chemistry between Janel Moloney and Bradley Whitford, who portrayed Josh Lyman, caught. path: Home / Threads & Relationships * Josh Lyman & Donna Moss Donnatella Moss, when did you start working for me?" "During the campaign." However, knowing you as I do, I'm afraid I can't trust you to spend the change wisely. Sep 12, But what those shows lack that The West Wing had in spades was a collection of .. Signature Episode: “In God We Trust,” wherein Vinick deals with the touchy Abbey Bartlet's birthday party and debates British/Irish relations with Toby. . Donna Moss (Janel Moloney): Josh Lyman's assistant and the.

The cherry on top is that Bartlet implies that a carving knife is supposed to be passed from father to son. After being encouraged to get immunity during the investigation into Bartlet's non disclosure because of the cost of lawyers, Charlie implicitly refuses, mentioning that accepting immunity implies lack of trust, and that he sticks to his team no matter what.

When Donna learns about the President's MS, her first response is to ask whether the President is in a lot of pain or discomfort.

Particularly heartwarming since pretty much everyone else who's reaction we've seen on learning the news has mainly been some combination of betrayal and anger at being lied to.

And when Joey is told, her first reaction is "How is the President? President, Kenny has been with me for eleven years. To trust me is to trust him. It's very subtle, but Kenny's lack of a response in this moment is kind of heartwarming in itself. Although it's rare for Kenny to speak for himself, if there was ever a time when it would have been justifiable, when it would have made sense for him to do so, it would have been this moment.

But he doesn't say a word in his own defense. He lets Joey do it. Clearly the trust between them goes both ways. The moment in Bartlet's famous "Two Cathedrals" monologue where he refers to Josh as his son. What was Josh Lyman? What did I ever do to Yours except praise His glory and His name? Or the scene where Bartlet gives his Secretary of Agriculture advice on how to run the country should something happen at the State of the Union.

You have a best friend? Is he smarter than you? Would you trust him with your life? That's your chief of staff.

The 15 Most Iconic Josh-Donna Moments in 'West Wing' History

The reason this scene is truly touching is because Leo, Bartlett's Chief of Staff, was standing nearby and heard the whole thing. This was during the story arc where Leo's alcoholism went public and he was getting pilloried by the President's more vocal critics.

This gets taken further in the later seasons with Leo's heart attack first pushing him out of the West Wing, then leaving him floundering for a place once CJ replaces him. A flashback to an early public appearance by president-elect Bartlet has him whisper to his friend "it should be you, Leo" which deeply touches the man. When the next Democratic ticket is being constructed and Matt Santos needs a running mate, Josh comes with instructions from the president that, "if he says no, I'm to kick his ass all over the schoolyard.

So who is it?

  • West Wing stars: Josh and Donna would still be together
  • Donna Moss

When Toby's ex-wife is expecting her children, he speaks to Leo about his concern that he won't truly love his children. Leo says that's ridiculous, not because all fathers love their children, but because he knows Toby will.

donna moss and josh lyman relationship trust

Later, when Toby meets his kids for the first time, he tells them: And after this scene, Toby becomes one of the strongest voices in favor of Bartlet invoking the 25th Amendment for the duration of Zoe's abduction, because "If somebody was hurting them, I'd drop napalm on Yellowstone to get them to stop, letting some prisoners out of jail wouldn't be nothing, and I've known my kids about forty-five minutes.

My- my kids have heads! How about in "In Excelsis Deo" when Toby uses the President's name in order to make sure a homeless Korean War veteran gets a burial with honors at Arlington.

She earlier told Charlie that she gets depressed this time of year because her sons both died in Vietnam around this time. I miss my boys. The United States Armed Forces granting permission to shoot at Arlington National Cemetery and providing a Navy Chaplain and a Marine Corps Honor Guard - all actual service members performing their actual roles in a military funeral - because the show's military liasons were impressed by the episode's passionate argument that no American servicemember's death should be treated in such an undignified way.

An unrelated scene from the same episode: Leo scolding Josh and Sam for visiting Sam's call-girl friend to see if she has any dirt on any Republicans they can use to fight the impending revelations about Leo's addictions saying "that's not what we do" and that he specifically asked them not to.

As Leo goes to leave, Josh blurts out, "We meant well. When Sam says that he already did apologize, Leo orders him to apologize to her again. The fact that he expresses indignation over how Laurie was treated, when plenty of people in his position wouldn't think twice about her, speaks volumes. The entire subplot with Bartlet's daughter Ellie in the episode of the same name.

It's clear that she and Bartlet have a difficult relationship, and after he accuses her of deliberately provoking a media fuss to make him unhappy "You sure didn't do it to make me happy!

She wasn't the only one. Or the subplot in the episode "Stirred" where Donna tries to get a proclamation in honor her favorite teacher, who is retiring. Bartlet calls her into the Oval Office to personally tell her that the teacher deserves one, but that he can't give it to her for political reasons Tell her where you are. Also heartwarming is the fact that Josh wrote the President a memo on Donna's behalf, despite knowing full well that there was no way the teacher was going to receive the honor Donna wanted her to.

At the end of "The Women of Qumar", when CJ has to dispassionately report the renewal of a military base in Qumar, a decision she was upset about the whole episode because of Qumar's barbaric treatment of women.

donna moss and josh lyman relationship trust

She falters for a moment, near tears, and looks up at Toby, who is standing in his usual spot behind the back window where only she can see him, in support of her. He catches her eye and taps himself over the heart with both hands, giving her the strength to continue the briefing.

Or the classic guy-in-the-hole speech from Leo. And the callback it gets later in the series from Josh. I'm gonna help you out, you know why? Because you're so obsessed with everyone you love dying that you're a compulsive fixer?

Bartlet's gift to Leo at the end of "Bartlet for America. In the final shot of the series, we see Bartlet flying home from the White House, looking at the same gift. It was returned to him following Leo's death, still pristine in its beautiful frame. The gift in question is a bar napkin. Leo had been stumbling about for days, struggling to figure out who - the one that Leo could trust above all others - could run for President.

And he finds himself writing the same thing down over and over. On that napkin are the words "Bartlet For America". Earlier in that episode, Leo is describing Bartlet preparing himself for a debate: He sees it as a genuine opportunity to change minds - also his best way of contributing to the team.

I love him so much. Toby to Sam on the eve of the special election in California: You're gonna lose, and you're gonna lose huge.

donna moss and josh lyman relationship trust

They're gonna throw rocks at you next week, and I wanted to be standing next to you when they did. Sam when he decided to run, especially his little story about the Republican wingnut candidate he met who wouldn't let go of his doomed campaign platform because "this is what I believe, and no candidate gets to run in my district without speaking to my issues.

Smart people who love you are gonna have your back. At the end of the episode, she's literally on her way out the door when Leo calls her into his office. He talks to her honestly about his own addictions and the fact that his father was a violent alcoholic; she says that her father also drank a lot.

He refuses to blame anyone else for his addictions, and tells her that he hasn't had a drink or taken a pill in six and a half years. You're not like what I thought you would be like. You haven't answered my question yet. When you saw my personnel file, when you saw I'd been through treatment, what when through your mind?

CJ Makes Josh Go on a Diet – West Wing S06 E03

My father used to Karen, what you did caused a lot of problems; for me, for the President, and for a lot of people we don't even know. But I'm not sure it wasn't a little bit brave. Then why don't you go unpack your carton and you and I will give each other a second chance? What makes it heartwarming is that Leo understands that she didn't do what she did to gain favour with anyone, or because she was being judgemental about his addictions, but because she was legitimately frightened by the idea that a man with Leo's history of substance abuse could wield so much power.

And that he gives her a second chance because it's important to him that she give him a second chance too. He doesn't have to care what she thinks of him. In "Two Cathedrals," Charlie comes out to the portico where Bartlet is standing in the storm to tell him that it's time to leave for the press conference.

He's wearing a coat and holding one for Bartlet, but Bartlet walks by without putting it on. Back inside, before catching up to him, Charlie lays Bartlet's coat on his desk All of the other staffers wear their coats. From the Saga of Josh and Donna: The episode 17 People. Donna tells Josh a story about how she was once in a car accident, and her then-boyfriend stopped for a beer with his buddies on his way to see her in the hospital.

Later in the episode, Josh says, "I'm just sayin'. If you were in an accident, I wouldn't stop for a beer. Yeah, that isn't it. Josh's expression when she wakes up, so concerned and hopeful, gets me every time. Not to mention that Donna's first words after surgery was saying Josh's name over and over.

And that she asked to see him before surgery, not her boyfriend. It is also very heartwarming that aside from Donna's new boyfriend nobody bats an eye at Josh leaving the White House during a major crisis to fly to Germany and be with Donna. They all seem to think it's perfectly reasonable given their close connection. Heck, even the reporters that cover the White House turn their questions to Toby instead of Josh, out of respect for his close relationship with Donna.

The scene in "Inauguration: And later in the same episode, Will's utterly flabbergasted reaction to his appointment as Deputy Communications Director. In the sixth season, presidential-candidate Matt Santos gives this gorgeous speech about the power of hope. It's a lovely speech, but what really makes it a Heartwarming Moment is that it's superimposed with President Bartlet slowly pulling himself with canes across the Oval Office after being nearly crippled by multiple sclerosis.

When the Santos team looks to be losing the primary while Matt Santos and his wife are mortgaging their house to keep the campaign afloat, Josh rushes to stop them from putting their financial future in jeopardy over a losing cause, and Matt tells Josh a story.

You know, when I got out of the Marines, I hadn't been around in my old neighborhood in Houston in a few years and I just got this job offer from the Pentagon, and it required a full FBI background check. After a few weeks the investigators came up to me and said "We can't give you the job.

We've interviewed all your old friends and neighbors, and they can't confirm anything. Not even your name. I see my neighbor's eleven and thirteen year old kids, they're sitting on the stoop, same as always. And they see me coming and they start running towards me and shouting "Tio Matt!

We told 'em we never heard of you! I am running for President at that Texas primary. And those kids are going to see me do it. In "He Shall, from Time to Time Jed, of all the things you could have kept from me. You haven't called me Jed since I was elected. Why didn't you tell me? It wouldn't have stopped me from getting you here. And I could have been a friend.

In Defense of Josh Lyman : thewestwing

You have been a friend. But when it was time to really Yes, Josh seems to expect that Donna will be his assistant forever.

That seems to be the relationship that Margaret has with his mentor and father figure, Leo, as well as President Bartlet with Mrs. Given that Margaret expected to follow Leo wherever he went post heart attack, and Josh's feelings about loyalty, it isn't hard to see how he expected Donna to always be there for him.

It isn't reasonable, of course. Donna proves herself more capable and more ambitious than the other assistants. She both wants and deserves a shot at bigger and better things. She nearly dies, and Josh drops everything to be by her side.

And when she finally returns, he tries to hold on so tightly to her that she slips through his fingers. His actions in the aftermath probably crystalized his feelings for her, so how could he ever risk her getting hurt again. Donna was right to quit, of course, but given his past, I think I'm willing to cut Josh a little break for trying to hold on as he did. Maybe the writing staff felt they made all of this pretty obvious, but I don't see it online.